‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd’ by Agatha Christie

Genre: Adult Fiction – Crime/Mystery

Published: 1926

Format: Paperback

Rating: ★★★★★

An absolutely brilliant mystery! Agatha Christie hasn’t managed to disappoint me yet and this is the best I’ve read so far. Her plotting of a murder mystery and the development of characters and their involvement in the plot is so intricate and nuanced that sometimes you’re not sure who you’re supposed to be expecting or what exactly happened.

The characters were so interesting, all more inter-locked than you could imagine, and so many red herrings that it was difficult to know what was real and what wasn’t. Hercule Poirot is portrayed almost as a bumbling man who just happened upon on the truth, when in reality he seems to have a brilliant mind and a knack for spotting lies, and connections. Dr Sheppard and his sister, Caroline, were intriguing – two different sides to the same coin in a way, and brilliant foils for each other.

Such a cast of characters and an unreliable narrator make for second- and third- guessing yourself as you try to figure out who the killer is. I never figured out who the killer was; it wasn’t even someone I ever expected! Christie always manages to surprise me, but this is the best yet! The ending alone could make it a 5-star book. Brilliantly written and what a twist!

‘The Mysterious Affair at Styles’ by Agatha Christie

Genre: Adult Fiction – Crime/Mystery

Published: 1920

Format: Paperback

Rating: ★★★★

I loved this book – the only criticism I can levy that stops it being a 5-star book was that I felt like I had no chance of guessing the murderer myself because many of the clues were withheld. I love to be able to try and guess, even if it’s rare that I get it right, but I felt like I didn’t have a chance.

But I love Poirot as a character even though the narrator, Arthur Hastings, was somewhat unreliable. It’s great to be able to see Poirot and his workings through someone else’s eyes. The only Christie books I’ve read before are ‘Murder on the Orient Express’ and ‘Hallowe’en Party’ but I did really enjoy this one. Christie has created such an interesting group of characters and U don’t think the story would work without any one of them.

There were a lot of red herrings, and I have to say the maps of the house really helped and I kept going back to them, especially when Poirot was revealing what happened, just to keep everything straight in my head. The plot was quite ingenious, and I didn’t see the end coming at all; it was a complete surprise, and that’s a great crime writer.

I’m moving straight onto ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd’ because I’m not quite ready to leave Agatha Christie alone yet! I want more of those ingenious storylines and fascinating characters, and to see how Poirot solves yet another murder.

‘Hallowe’en Party’ by Agatha Christie

Genre: Adult Fiction – Crime/Mystery

Published: 1969

Format: Paperback

Rating: ★★★★

This was our book club read for October 2023 for Hallowe’en!  The first thing I have to say is that I saw the ‘A Haunting in Venice’ film before I read this book. I was surprised reading this book about how little the film actually resembled the book – some of the characters (Poirot, Ariadne Oliver, and Rowena Drake) are the same, and it starts at a Hallowe’en Party. Some names of the characters are the same but used in a different way (Olga Seminoff, Leslie Ferrier, and Joyce Reynolds) but the storyline and mystery as well as the location are entirely different. Both are excellent stories, but can the film be said to be based on the book? I’m not sure except perhaps very very loosely.

Just talking about the book, it’s only the second Poirot mystery I’ve read after ‘Murder on the Orient Express’, but just like ‘Murder on the Orient Express’ I really enjoyed it. Poirot is such a fascinating character, so different from the people around him, victims, and suspects. But he has such a sharp and clever mind, making connections between things that many people wouldn’t see. It takes a special person to be able to do that.

As to the mystery and storyline, because the book was so different to the film that I’d already seen it didn’t spoil my enjoyment at all because I wasn’t sure if the killer would be the same as in the film or not (and I won’t spoil it here!) and I thoroughly enjoyed reading how the story developed and intertwined with previous crimes committed in a small English village.

Putting the film title in such big letters on this version is misleading. People will expect a book based in Venice when the book actually has no link to Venice whatsoever. One of my pet peeves is when movies are made with a different title to the book, and they re-release the book with the film title splashed all over it! Please just stick to the book title; this is a book after all and not a film!

Monthly Reading Summary – October 2023

Top Book of the Month – ‘Trouble’ by Lex Croucher

Book Club Book This Month – ‘Hallowe’en Party’ by Agatha Christie

Books Read This Month:

Books Bought This Month:

  • ‘Hex and the City’ by Kate Johnson
  • ‘The Mysterious Affair at Styles’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘Death in the Clouds’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘Death on the Nile’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘After the Funeral’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘Cat Among the Pigeons’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘Murder on the Orient Express’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘Hallowe’en Party’ by Agatha Christie
  • ‘Hunting the Falcon: Henry VIII, Anne Boleyn and the Marriage that Shook Europe’ by John Guy & Julia Fox

Statistics:

  • Books Read – 5
  • Currently Reading – 2
  • TBR – 223
  • Fiction – 4 (80.00%)
  • Non-Fiction – 1 (20.00%)
  • Male Author – 1 (20.00%)
  • Female Author – 3 (60.00%)
  • Non-Binary Author – 1 (60.00%)
  • Multiple Authors – 0 (0.00%)
  • Paperback – 5 (100.00%)
  • Hardback – 0 (0.00%)
  • eBook – 0 (0.00%)
  • Audiobook – 0 (0.00%)
  • Total Pages Read – 1,495
  • Average Pages Per Book – 299
  • Hours Listened – 0.00
  • Average Star Rating – 3.6

‘Murder on the Orient Express’ by Agatha Christie

“The murderer is with us—on the train now…” Just after midnight, a snowdrift stops the Orient Express in its tracks. The luxurious train is surprisingly full for the time of the year, but by the morning it is one passenger fewer. An American tycoon lies dead in his compartment, stabbed a dozen times, his door locked from the inside. Isolated and with a killer in their midst, detective Hercule Poirot must identify the murderer – in case he or she decides to strike again. [Description from Waterstones]

Hercule Poirot #10

It has taken me a while to get around to reading any Agatha Christie, though I have been meaning to for a while. I certainly wasn’t disappointed! ‘Murder on the Orient Express’ was a thoroughly enjoyable read and an excellent murder mystery. It is a classic and I can understand why.

Christie really manages to bring characters alive with just a few words – she manages to say a lot succinctly, which is something that I think other authors could do with. I was particularly intrigued in this novel with the relationship and interplay between Poirot and Bouc. Poirot manages to make the solution seem obvious when it is pointed out, but I didn’t guess the solution in the end (I am quite surprised that I didn’t get spoiled to be honest!). The mystery itself was intriguing as it seemed to combine two different mysteries into one, and it wasn’t until the final pages that you began to understand how the two mysteries intertwined so closely. The different clues and red herrings like the pipe cleaner, handkerchief, and burnt letter all pointed to different people so it was difficult to choose who the culprit was, and I kept changing my mind.

Poirot as a character is interesting as the way that his brain works is obviously extremely logical and he sees things that other people miss. It makes for very interesting reading as we hear what Poirot feels and what he thinks of the different people and clues, which is often very different to what those around him think of the same things. I find the whole psychology thrilling – especially as we begin to discover the pasts of the different characters. I just wish that there was more of how Poirot guessed what had happened, and what went on in his head, rather than just seeing the results.

I saw the 2017 film of this book starring Kenneth Branagh as Poirot just after I finished the novel, but I was actually pretty disappointed by it. I loved Branagh as Poirot, but the things that were changed from the novel didn’t sit right I didn’t feel, but I’d be interested to know what others think. I am really looking forward to reading more Agatha Christie, however, in the future, and it is something that I definitely will continue to read and enjoy!